Skip to record
MassachusettsMistrial · Sept 4, 2026
Cora Clancy5 yearsDawson Clancy3 yearsCallan Clancy8 months

Commonwealth v. Lindsay Clancy

She knew.

Mental illness is not a verdict. On January 24, 2023, Lindsay Clancy measured a drive time, sent her husband out of the house, and killed Cora, Dawson, and Callan. The question Massachusetts asked was whether she retained substantial capacity. The record says she did.

Charges

Three counts of first-degree murder

The act

Not guilty. The killings were stipulated.

Trial

July 20 – September 4, 2026

Result

Mistrial. Hung jury after seven days of deliberation.

The argument

Two tests. She clears both.

Competency

She could be tried

Competency asks whether a defendant understands the court now. Judge Sullivan found she entered a stipulation of the killings knowingly and voluntarily. That finding is not in serious dispute. It is also not the finding that decides guilt.

Responsibility

She could be guilty

Criminal responsibility asks what her mind could do on January 24. Prosecution experts — Heilbrun, Saathoff — said she appreciated wrongfulness and controlled the sequence. The phone, the maps, and the 14-second callback say the same.

From the stand

“She retained an awareness of the illegality of killing others, including killing her children.”

Dr. Kirk Heilbrun · prosecution expert

Eight exhibits

Capacity leaves a trail.

All evidence
  1. 01

    She measured the clock

    The Apple Maps search was not idle. After picking a restaurant farther than usual, she looked up how long the drive would take. Prosecutors told the jury the plot is visible on the phone beginning about 4:00 p.m. — an hour before the killings.

  2. 02

    She emptied the house on purpose

    Two stops, not one. CVS in Kingston and ThreeV in Plymouth. She confirmed the pharmacy had a product before she sent him. Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague: she plotted to be alone, and she used the drive time to estimate how much time she would have.

  3. 03

    She could still do ordinary things

    A correct takeout order. A 14-second callback about stool softener, placed while the phone was locked. Driving a car that morning. A pediatric visit. Snow-day photographs. The hostess heard no slur, no impairment. Function is not a side note. It is the proof of capacity.

  4. 04

    She chose the method, the room, and the tool

    Sprague to the jury: she had to choose where — the basement. She had to choose how — strangulation. She had to choose with what — an exercise band. Dr. Gregory Saathoff noted that the voice she later described never told her any of that.

  5. 05

    She paused, then continued

    Patrick's call came in the middle of the interval. She did not answer, then called back, gave the right instruction, and returned to what she was doing. Saathoff: that interruption 'indicated that she had control of the sequence of what she was doing throughout.'

  6. 06

    The motive was not a hallucination

    Dr. Kirk Heilbrun, who spent nearly 180 hours on the file, rejected acute command psychosis. He concluded she killed the children so they would not 'suffer' after she killed herself. That is a recognized pattern — altruistic filicide. It is a terrible reason. It is still a reason. Reasons are the opposite of a break from reality.

  7. 07

    The voice appeared for 18 minutes

    Heilbrun: she reported the command hallucination only for the 18 minutes or so it took to kill the children. 'To put it mildly, that would be a very, very unusual pattern.' Saathoff: the voice then stopped. 'Committing the act is not curative of the voice. I've not ever seen that.'

  8. 08

    The people who treated her did not see psychosis

    Therapist Latiesha Dukes testified Clancy had intrusive suicidal thoughts and anxiety that something would happen to the children — and showed no signs of psychosis or mania. Dr. Sejal Shah, who examined her days later at Brigham and Women's, described an organized, goal-directed thought process. A treating clinician, Dr. Tufts, did not believe she had psychosis and said she had never expressed a plan to kill the children.

After the hung jury

A deadlock is not an answer.

After seven days, the jury wrote: “It is with a heavy heart that we report we are unable to come to a unanimous decision, and we will not be able to.” That is a failure of unanimity, not a finding that she lacked capacity. The Plymouth County district attorney may retry her. The next hearing is September 29, 2026. The evidence in this record has not receded.